BlogRoom.com -- Independent wine reviews on bottles from all over the world: 2008 Dona Paula Malbec

Back to Main Page
90+ Rated, Under $20
- BlogRoom Reviews 90+ Rated Wines Under $20
BlogRoom.com Recently Rated Wines
Wine Reviews
BlogRoom.com on Twitter
BlogRoom.com Special Sections
Wine Resources You Really Can Use
- CostcoWineBlog.com
- Vintage Ratings: Every year, every region
About this Site
BlogRoom.com was launched as an exploration into the world of wine. I was always interested in learning more about wine, but the resources for those of us who are relatively early on in the journey seemed to be clouded with too many poetic descriptions and elaborate phrases that meant nothing to me when I read them. It seemed like someone was randomly picking adjectives from the dictionary and claiming to be breaking new ground. So I thought it would be fun to write reviews myself with the goal of cutting through the clutter to help me, and the readers of the site, find great wine to try. It’s a subjective process but by taking a straight up approach to reviews, I hope that it helps people enjoy a good bottle and find wines that work best for their tastes. Or at the very least, compels people to try new wine, which is what this is all about. – Radcliffe, BlogRoom.com Editor
About the Ratings
We are rating wines on the standard 100 point scale. NOTE: Some early entries were marked on a 1 to 20 scale, but that was changed in July 2009 to reflect the more commonly used rating system, based on reader feedback. Where we see a strong value we may boost the score a point or two. The Gold, Silver and Bronze distinctions are for wines that we find to stand out in their class and/or offer spectacular value. And of course, the Value Picks, are just excellent buys.
Contact
I can be contacted at: blogroom(at)yahoo(dot)com. I welcome suggestions from readers on bottles I should try.
Quick Search

Search only in titles: Keyword:

Search in:

Date Range:

Advanced Search

Basic Search
Monthly Archives
Syndicate

2008 Dona Paula Malbec

I reviewed the 2005 vintage of the Dona Paula Malbec back in December when I served it at a dinner party at my house and really enjoyed it. So I was curious what the 2008 bottle would offer. It certainly would be a young wine, and I distinctly remember the refinement of the 2005.

Over the years these Malbecs from Dona Paula continue to pull down high ratings, and the 2008 vintage will fall quite nicely in the succession. It lacked a little of that refinement that starts to come from 3+ years in the bottle, but was still smooth and flavorful. Plus this bottle was only $11 when I paid closer to $17 for the 05. So I might grab another one to hold on to for later.

I'm going to give this one a slightly lower rating than the 05 which I gave 14 out of 20. I'll still drop it in the value picks though, and would recommend trying it.

BlogRoom.com Rating: 13 out of 20

BlogRoom.com *Value Pick*